S15: Connect Four - Robotic Player
Contents
- 1 Grading Criteria
- 2 Konnector (Artificially-Intelligent Connect Four Robot)
- 2.1 Abstract
- 2.2 Objectives & Introduction
- 2.3 Team Members & Responsibilities
- 2.4 Demonstration Video
- 2.5 Schedule
- 2.6 Parts List & Cost
- 2.7 Design & Implementation
- 2.8 Testing & Technical Challenges
- 2.9 Conclusion
- 2.10 References
Grading Criteria
- How well is Software & Hardware Design described?
- How well can this report be used to reproduce this project?
- Code Quality
- Overall Report Quality:
- Software Block Diagrams
- Hardware Block Diagrams
- Schematic Quality
- Quality of technical challenges and solutions adopted.
Konnector (Artificially-Intelligent Connect Four Robot)
Abstract
Play Connect Four against an Artificially Intelligent robot with variable difficulty. Prepare to test your ability to think into the future and your proficiency at connecting your pieces against an ideal player. Connect Four
Objectives & Introduction
The objectives of this project is to implement a robotic connect four player with the same capabilities as a human being with respect to the task of connecting pieces by inserting them into one of seven columns at the top of the board. Just as a human can see where his opponent has played his move and can insert his next move into the board, this robot will implement imitations of these basic human abilities.
Team Members & Responsibilities
Matthew Carlis (Jack of all Trades) - Hardware/Mechanical,
Artificial Intelligence,
System Architect,
Technical Writer.
Alexander Koumis (Image/Driver Guru) - Drivers,
Image Processing,
Software Interfaces.
Demonstration Video
The following is a link to a video of a student playing the robot on demonstration/presentation day.
Schedule
| Story# | Points | Task | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 15 | Motor Controller | Write a Stepper motor driver with variable frequency capabilities with constant linear acceleration. This driver should slowly speed up the motor and slowly bring it down while being capable of mapping PWM frequency to pulley frequency. |
| 2 | 10 | Bluetooth Socket. | The micro-controller will be run in combination with a workstation using Bluetooth message passing. The workstation will implement the AI programming where the micro-controller simply tells the workstation through Bluetooth where each move is made by the human and is returned the column number of where to insert the robots next piece. The workstation will implement a Python program interface. |
| 3 | 20 | AI Brain. (It's alive!) | A Python program running on an workstation will implement the "Brain" of the robot where messages are passed between the micro-controller and workstation through Bluetooth. This program will determine where the robot will insert his next move based on which column the human inserts into as reported through the Bluetooth message protocol. |
| 4 | 30 | Mechanical System. | The mechanical system be capable of inserting it's own pieces using linear motion and a stepper motor. The robot will drop his piece into a funnel device which is driven over the column for which the robot wishes to play. After his human opponent has inserted his piece the robots eyes will detect the location of the humans insertion and reply by inserting his next piece. |
| 5 | 25 | The Eyes. | Using the pixy camera to determine the current configuration of the Connect Four board for the robotic player. Using statistical filtering by oversampling the frames the robot will be see each piece as it is inserted. |
| Story# | Points | Story | Burn-down | Time Invested | Actual |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 15 | Motor Controller | 15 | 15 Hours | 14% |
| 2 | 10 | Bluetooth Socket. | 10 | 3 Hours | 4% |
| 3 | 20 | AI Brain. (It's alive!) | 20 | 18 Hours | 14% |
| 4 | 30 | Mechanical System. | 30 | 30+ Hours | 29% |
| 5 | 25 | The Eyes. | 25 | 40+ Hours | 39% |
| Event# | Date | Task | Actual |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3/1 | Spec out Design | Completed: Started the system hardware/mechanical specs and materials ordering. Software interfaces are well defined, but not implemented. |
| 2 | 3/18 | Ordered Materials | Completed: Completed mechanical design/research and ordered the majority of the significant materials. (Stepper motor, timing belt/pulleys, liner motion accessories) |
| 3 | 4/1 | Structure Materials | Completed: Received and obtained the majority of the significant materials for the mechanical structure. |
| 4 | 4/20 | Major Milestone | Completed: Bluetooth interface, Stepper Motor Driver, Mechanical specs/ordered, AI implementation. |
| 5 | 4/27 | Projected | ToDo: Finish assembling the mechanical, add linear acceleration to motor driver. |
| 6 | 5/25 | Major Milestone | Pixy Camera integration with the completed mechanical system. Interface a stepper motor, stepper driver, servo, and camera together. |
Parts List & Cost
Give a simple list of the cost of your project broken down by components. Do not write long stories here.
| Qty (Extra) | Description | Manufacturer | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Stepper Motor Driver 3A | SmartSain | $19.99 |
| 1 | Stepper Motor | Lin Engineering | $45.90 |
| 1 | 24V-40W PSU. | CircuitSpecialists | $14.79 |
| 1 | Pixy Camera CMUcam5 | Pixy | $69.99 |
| 1 | XBee Bluetooth | XBee | $27.95 |
| 2 | Timing Pulley's | N/A | $11.95 (each) |
| 1 | Timing Belt | N/A | $9.95 |
| 4 | Linear Rail Guide | N/A | $3.95 (each) |
| 2 | Linear Bearing w/Platform | N/A | $6.95 (each) |
| 2 | 8mm Linear Motion Rail/Shaft Steel | N/A | $15.25 (each) |
Design & Implementation
System Diagram
The following graphic provides a high-level representation of the system's various software/hardware/human interfaces:
Hardware Design
Discuss your hardware design here. Show detailed schematics, and the interface here.
Hardware Interface
In this section, you can describe how your hardware communicates, such as which BUSes used. You can discuss your driver implementation here, such that the Software Design section is isolated to talk about high level workings rather than inner working of your project.
- Physical Layer Interfaces
- SPI - Pixy Camera
- Bluetooth - Laptop Communication
- Stepper Motor Driver - 3A capable with inductive load isolation.
- PWM (stepper) - 1 Wire PWM with 2 Control Signals.
- PWM (servo) - 2 Wire PWM.
- Isolation CPU I/O from the stepper motor's inductive load. This prevents ground bounce from damaging low voltage components.
Software Design
The system's software interfaces are comprised of the following components (organized by their respective hardware hosts):
- Laptop
- SJSU One
Bluetooth Socket Interface
The robot implements a Bluetooth interface between a python program running on an Intel64 Linux machine and the SJSU One robot. This interface is used to send a message from the robot about where the opponent has played his move to the AI on the laptop where the next move calculation is performed. The next move is then returned to the robot over Bluetooth from the Python AI and then the motors are used by the SJSU One to insert the next move into the board and watch for the opponents following move repeating until the game ends. The SJSU one is interfaced using the UART0/printf to send/receive over this Bluetooth channel. The Python Bluetooth socket implements two synchronous user space threaded where a child thread is blocking on receives, waiting for data from the robot’s eyes about where his opponent has played his move. The child thread parses on a regular expression timeout loop implementing a synchronous interface/queue to the brain of the AI which is calculating potential moves. When the AI’s/parent thread synchronizes with the Bluetooth socket’s child thread over a queue the AI calculates for another 5 seconds before returning the next move for the robot which uses motors driven by the SJSU one to insert his move. The child-thread implements a synchronous kill where the block on receive times out every few milliseconds and checks to see if the child-thread should self destruct. When kill is triggered by SIG-INT, the AI or an exception the socket kills the data send/receive, reads all of the data from the buffer, and closes the Bluetooth socket. This ensures the kernel properly re-allocates its resources to the Bluetooth driver allowing clean reconnections.
""" game_socket.py
"""
class GameSocket(threading.Thread):
def __init__(self):
def _teardown(self):
def run(self): # Blocks on receive from the bluetooth.
def connect(self):
def _send_data(self): # Asynchronous send.
def get_move(self): # Synchronizes threads on the queue.Connect 4 AI
The Connect Four AI was completed using the The MiniMax Algorithm with Alpha/Beta Pruning. MiniMax/Alpha-Beta use a heuristic calculation which essentially comes down to a numerical value which estimates the effectiveness of a particular move or state of the board based on the number of connected pieces. The algorithm works it's way down the game tree evaluating the heuristic value for the leaves of the adversarial search tree in an attempt to maximize the AI's performance by backing these values up the recursion stack and making decisions based on the effectiveness of moves in the distant future. The AI's goal is to find the subtree of the current root which evaluates to the highest performance according to the heuristic.
Our heuristic is extremely simple in that it only looks at the maximum number of connected pieces per player at any given configuration of the board. It also takes into account the fact that some moves cannot be extended further because they may be buried by the opponents pieces or into a wall of the board. If a move cannot be extended further the heuristic ignores these pieces only looking for positions/moves that he can extend. This is no where near a perfect heuristic for Connect Four and it can result in somewhat unpredictable behavior in certain circumstances, but at times the AI performs flawlessly. Coming up with a more effective heuristic is somewhat mathematical process for Connect Four therefore we took the shortest path to designing our AI under the given time constraints.
Alpha/Beta Pruning pruning is a technique which allows the algorithm to dynamically cut subtrees off during evaluation by allowing MiniMax to detect when a certain subtree is worse for him than an already existing option. In other words the Algorithm will try to not expand subtrees which are obviously advantageous to the opponent. This allows the algorithm to go twice as deep into the Adversarial Search Tree where the Time Complexity Before Alpha-Beta pruning of MiniMax is O(b^d) where improved to O(b^(d/2)) using Alpha-Beta pruning. This lets us look twice as far into the future with the same code basically. Memory of MiniMax with/without Alpha-Beta pruning is O(d).
""" four_connect.py
"""
class GameBoard(object):
def __init__(self, width, height, game_board):
def __repr__(self):
def __str__(self):
def terminal_check(self): # Is the game over? i.e four in a row?
def insert(self, column, symbol):
def get_best_heuristic(self, symbol): # Get this symbols best heuristic from this board.
class GameNode(object): # Has a GameBoard()
def __init__(self, parent=None):
def get_state(self): # Get the state of the board.
def get_parent(self): # Get the reference to the parent of this node.
class ConnectFour(object): # Has a GameNode() i.e the current state.
# Has a GameSocket() to interface with the robot.
def __init__(self, player_first=False):
def print_map(self, no_move=False):
def insert(self, column, player):
def state_machine(self): # Turn/Taking
def _next_turn_event(self): # Calls MiniMax() and receives opponents move.GameTask
The GameTask is essentially the master task for the Connect Four robotic environment. This task is responsible for I/O through bluetooth to the Laptop, dispatching the Stepper Motor to insert pieces into the board, and enabling the Pixy Camera to detect the column of the most recently inserted piece by the opponent. This task can be though of as the dispatcher who watches over subtasks for completion and manages the overall operations of the game. Using FreeRTOS Queues to synchronize each task around an TX/RX queue for scheduling.
MotorTask
- Motor task is responsible for stepping the stepper motor a certain number of decimal rotations according to what is received by the GameTask in the MotorTask RX Queue. This task sends the platform over the column for which to insert, and then activates a servo motor that drops the chip into the board before stepping back to the home position of the platform (All the way Right). The job of this task is to poll the registers which determine the number of steps that have occurred and correlating this to a number of rotations. Once the process of inserting a piece is completed the MotorTask signals GameTask that it has completed using a FreeRTOS Queue.
- Stepper Motor Control was performed using the MCPWM registers & a single PWM Pin with implementation of variable frequency and hooks for acceleration in the future. The Stepper motor driver isolates the SJSU-One board from the stepper motor utilizing internal LED's with paired photo-transistors to avoid damage to the CPU from inductive ground bounces. This motor controller interfaces the CPU with pins for a Step Enable, Direction Signal, and Motor Enable pins from the micro-controller to the stepper motor driver.
PixyTask
Drivers for the Pixy were designed using Ozmekian system principles (every machine characteristic/action has a corresponding human analogue). The Pixy's primary tasks as part of Konnector is to send the location and coordinates of human-inserted Connect 4 game chips to the SJSU One board. This involves recording location/coordinate information of incoming blobs, performing statistical analysis on said blobs, and subsequently notifying other system components once a human chip-insertion has been detected. The Pixy's software interface is therefore comprised of the classes PixyBrain, PixyEyes, and PixyMouth, each one encompassing the corresponding facilities that would be required of a human assuming the same role.
Following the same analogy, the 'Pixy' class can be thought of as the system's consciousness/soul, defining actions for each component to take in response to system states. 'PixyTask' then assumes the role of the system's physical body, comprised of all of its individual components, animated by actions invoked by the consciousness during run-time.
The system's states are enumerated as follows: (Github):
enum State_t
{
CALIB = 16,
WAITING_FOR_HUMAN = 17,
WAITING_FOR_BOT = 18,
ERROR = 19,
RESET = 0x01, // SW(1)
EMA_ALPHA_UP = 0x02, // SW(2)
EMA_ALPHA_DOWN = 0x04, // SW(3)
SW_4 = 0x08 // SW(4)
} eState, eLastState;The CALIB state is run at system startup, constructing a 6x7 grid of chip positions to be referenced later in the game (full discussion).
The WAITING_FOR_HUMAN and WAITING_FOR_BOT states encompass the system's behavior when waiting for human chip-insertion, and the AI's next-move instruction, respectively.
RESET, EMA_ALPHA_UP/DOWN and SW_4 are mapped to the SJSU One's push-buttons , respectively, with RESET wiping current calibration settings/game state, and EMA_ALPHA_UP/DOWN allowing run-time adjustment of the tolerance parameter used in the chip-detection algorithm.
Unexpected data values/return codes cause the system to enter the ERROR state, where accumulated error messages are retreived from an error queue.
PixyTask invokes state reactions by calling vAction() within the bool run(void*) function (a task-runner interface):
bool run(void *p)
{
pPixy->vAction();
return true;
}void vAction() is then defined as:
void vAction()
{
eLastState = eState;
xFuncMap->vResponse(eState)();
}xFuncMap is prepopulated with lambda functions in response to every possible State_t key. For example, handlers for WAITING_FOR_HUMAN and WAITING_FOR_BOT are set as follows:
xFuncMap->vSetHandler(WAITING_FOR_HUMAN, [&] ()
{
// Blocks until N chips are sampled
pPixyBrain->lSampleChips(pPixyEyes.get());
eState = WAITING_FOR_BOT;
});
xFuncMap->vSetHandler(WAITING_FOR_BOT, [&] ()
{
PixyCmd_t xBotInsertCmd;
// Blocks until command received over shared queue
if (xQueueReceive(getSharedObject(shared_PixyQueue), &xBotInsertCmd))
{
PixyBrain->lBotInsert(xBotInsertCmd);
eState = WAITING_FOR_HUMAN;
}
});These reactive symantics are made possible by the templated 'FuncMap_t' utility struct, allowing function pointers (std::function) to be stored in a map, invoked later in response to key values of arbitrary type:
template<typename KEY_T, typename FUN_T, typename ... ARG_T>
struct FuncMap_t
{
/* The core std::map object, mapping KEY_T's to std::function's */
map<KEY_T, function<FUN_T(ARG_T ... xArgs)>> fpMap;
/* Method used to insert (KEY_T, std::function) key/value pairs */
void vSetHandler(KEY_T xElem, function<FUN_T(ARG_T ... xArgs)> fnHandler)
{
fpMap[xElem] = fnHandler;
}
/* Method called during run-time to invoke stored lambda function */
function<FUN_T(ARG_T ... xArgs)>& vResponse(KEY_T xElem)
{
return fpMap[xElem];
}
};PixyBrain
Effort is taken to compartmentalize computational duties solely to PixyBrain. #PixyEyes performs no role other than to record seen blocks over a certain time period, providing this information to PixyBrain when queried. PixyBrain uses this information, along with prior knowledge of current game state, to determine when the human opponent has inserted a new chip. PixyBrain then delegates #PixyMouth to forward this information to the Python AI, sending the (int) column value over a shared FreeRTOS queue.
Corner calibration
The first action executed by the system is to determine pixel coordinates (x, y) of each of the board's four corner chip slots. A predefined number of blocks are sampled from the stream sent from #PixyEyes , each one adding to one of four running averages depending on the quadrant they fall in. Assuming only the top left, top right, bottom left, and bottom right slots are occupied by the set calibration chip color, the final average coordinates are used to construct the full grid of slot locations.
Insertion detection
The smallest distance between all possible next chip positions (whose coordinates are determined during camera calibration ) and incoming blocks from PixyEyes is calculated for block. An exponential moving average is kept for the likelihood of each chip's being one of the three possible colors, NONE, GREEN, or RED. Once the system has reached a certain level of confidence that the chip is a certain (none-NONE) color, the column number is sent through #PixyMouth to notify the AI of the location of the chip.
PixyEyes
Determining the location of chips with PixyEyes involves sampling data incoming over SPI. Example code [was provided] for this purpose but, unfortunately, did not function correctly under FreeRTOS' tight memory constraints. Alternative drivers were written, attempting to conform to the [defined protocol], where data is sent in 14-byte blocks as follows:
Bytes 16-bit word Description ---------------------------------------------------------------- 0, 1 y sync: 0xaa55=normal object, 0xaa56=color code object 2, 3 y checksum (sum of all 16-bit words 2-6) 4, 5 y signature number 6, 7 y x center of object 8, 9 y y center of object 10, 11 y width of object 12, 13 y height of object
After the block is populated, it is added to a static-sized std::vector<PixyBlock>, used later by PixyBrain to determine chip location.
PixyMouth
PixyMouth is invoked by #PixyBrain to send the column of human chip-insertion over a FreeRTOS queue , which unblocks #GameTask to send the command to the AI module listening on the Bluetooth socket.
Implementation
This section includes implementation, but again, not the details, just the high level. For example, you can list the steps it takes to communicate over a sensor, or the steps needed to write a page of memory onto SPI Flash. You can include sub-sections for each of your component implementation.
Testing & Technical Challenges
Describe the challenges of your project. What advise would you give yourself or someone else if your project can be started from scratch again? Make a smooth transition to testing section and described what it took to test your project.
Include sub-sections that list out a problem and solution, such as:
My Issue #1
Discuss the issue and resolution.
Task Priority was set to high on the Pixy/Camera task and was causing SPI/UART to not work properly. This was fixed by reducing the priority from HIGH (Which was an obvious mistake) to LOW which is much more appropriate since the task does not require any instantaneous operation or scheduling.
Conclusion
Conclude your project here. You can recap your testing and problems. You should address the "so what" part here to indicate what you ultimately learnt from this project. How has this project increased your knowledge?
Project Video
Upload a video of your project and post the link here.
Project Source Code
- Sourceforge Source Code Link (Project Baseline)
- Connect Four:
References
Acknowledgement
Any acknowledgement that you may wish to provide can be included here.
References Used
List any references used in project.
Appendix
You can list the references you used.
